logo
  • Home
  • Grocery List
Your Library

Maple Pumpkin Pie

By
Made it!
Log In to mark as Made
8 Servings
1 h 45 min
Foodys made it 0 time
No ratings yet
Img Preview
Prep ahead: Dough can be made ahead. Bake, cool & fridge pie 1 day ahead
pumpkinholiday piethanksgiving pieholidaypie recipeholiday bakingthanksgiving dessertPrep AheadDessert

This pie is always a huge hit at Thanksgiving. It's perfectly silky and smooth, and not too sweet. The key is to par-bake the crust before adding the filling and baking it - this prevents the bottom from getting soggy. It is an extra step, but it's so so worth it! When doing this you have to place something heavy on top of the pie dough to keep it from puffing up - use pie weights if you have it, otherwise dried beans do the trick just as well.

The filling itself is made up of a number of easily findable ingredients, and the maple syrup really adds a nice depth of flavor. Serve with whipped cream and / or vanilla ice cream, and your Thanksgiving guests will be thanking you!

I like to make my own pie dough for this recipe, and I use a food processor to make it (it takes less than 5 minutes!) but you can of course do it by hand in a mixing bowl or buy a pre-made pie shell (in the freezer section) if you prefer.

This recipe works for a 9-10inch pie pan. Serves 8

Sign up for a FREE account to save these recipes

Special Equipment

Rimmed Baking Sheet
Small Whisk
Rolling Pin
Pie Weights
Pie Pan
Plastic Wrap
Food Processor

Ingredients

For the Pie Dough
all purpose flour
granulated sugar
kosher salt
cold unsalted butter, cubed
ice water
Pumpkin Pie Filling
15 oz can pumpkin puree
firmly packed light brown sugar
good maple syrup
whole milk
heavy cream
large eggs
all purpose flour
vanilla extract
ground cinnamon
kosher salt
ground ginger
ground nutmeg

Directions