logo
  • Home
  • Grocery List
Your Library

Accidentally the Best Christmas Sugar Cookies!

By
Made it!
Log In to mark as Made
1 Batch
45 min
Foodys made it 0 time
No ratings yet
Img Preview
Prep ahead: dough can be made a few hours ahead and refrigerated wrapped
dessertcream cheese cookiesugar cookiechristmas cookieholiday bakingKid FriendlyPot Luck

Growing up, my mom always made these delicious cream cheese press sugar cookies for the Holidays. The cream cheese takes a regular sugar cookie to new levels - but the consistency is soft and requires a press.

Two years ago I attempted to make a double batch of my mom's cream cheese sugar cookies and absent-mindedly forgot to double the butter, even though I doubled everything else (I was pregnant at the time, so I blame that). The dough was too stiff to put through a cookie press.

Determined not to waste the huge batch of dough I just made, I realized the consistency was pretty similar to a traditional sugar cookie, so I decided to roll them out instead and cut out Holiday cookies with cookie cutters. The result was truly the best sugar cookie I have ever had - because, well, cream cheese! Also, you can keep combining and rolling out scraps, getting lots of bang for your buck.

So this Holiday Season, give these "Accidental Sugar Cookies" a try!

Yields: a ton of cookies.

Sign up for a FREE account to save these recipes

Special Equipment

Rimmed Baking Sheet
Rolling Pin
Cookie Cutter
Parchment Paper
Stand Mixer

Ingredients

unsalted butter, at room temperature (2 sticks)
regular cream cheese (not whipped), softened
sugar
vanilla extract
egg yolks
all purpose flour
food coloring, optional
Cookie Decorations / Toppings
powdered sugar
milk or water, plus more as needed for consistency
sprinkles, of choice

Directions